Canada-wide · Independent mortgage team Ready to talk? Book a call
Mortgage Momentum · Modern Mortgage Management
Home  /  Tools  /  Rent vs Buy

Rent or buy? See the real difference

Renting is not throwing money away, and buying is not always the win people assume. This tool compares your net worth under each path over time, counting appreciation, equity, and what you could earn investing instead.

A fair comparison: the renter invests the down payment and any monthly savings. Estimates only.

If you buy
Home value at end$0
Mortgage still owed$0
Net worth (after selling costs)$0
If you rent
Total rent paid$0
Investments grow to$0

Email me these results

Get a copy of your numbers, and we'll follow up with your options. No obligation.

The honest way to compare renting and buying

The old line that "rent is throwing money away" ignores half the picture. Owning has costs a renter never pays: property tax, maintenance, closing costs, mortgage interest, and the realtor fees when you sell. The fair question is not "which has a monthly payment" but which leaves you wealthier after the years you plan to stay, once you count home appreciation and the equity you build against what a renter could earn by investing the down payment instead.

What tips the answer

  • How long you stay. Buying usually wins the longer you hold, because upfront and selling costs get spread over more years.
  • Home appreciation vs investment returns. If markets outpace housing, renting and investing can come out ahead.
  • The gap between rent and ownership costs. A big monthly gap, invested, adds up for the renter.

Thinking of buying? See what you qualify for with the pre-qualification calculator and what it would cost to close with the land transfer & closing cost calculator.

This is an estimate to guide the decision, not financial advice. Your real answer depends on your rate, market, and plans, which is exactly what we help you map out.

Good to know

Rent vs buy FAQs

Is renting really throwing money away?
Not necessarily. Renters avoid property tax, maintenance, mortgage interest and selling costs, and can invest their down payment. Over short stays or in expensive markets, renting and investing can beat buying. Over longer holds, buying usually wins.
How many years until buying pays off?
It varies, but the longer you stay, the more buying tends to win, because the large upfront and selling costs are spread over more years and more equity is built. This calculator lets you test different holding periods.
Why does the renter's investment return matter?
A renter can invest the down payment and any monthly savings instead of tying it up in a home. If those investments grow faster than the home appreciates, renting can come out ahead. That is why the comparison counts both.
Should I buy if I might move soon?
If you may move within a few years, buying often does not pay off once you include land transfer tax, legal fees and realtor commissions. The calculator shows this clearly when you set a short stay.

Ready to make the move make sense?

We help you weigh renting against buying with real numbers, then find the mortgage that makes owning work, at no cost.

Get my quote Book a call